
A young, remote team bought at about 60% of market value without a hard sell, and the method is repeatable.
Key Takeaways
- To buy real estate below market value means paying less than the most probable price in an open, competitive sale, usually because the seller values speed, certainty or relief.
- Nathan Umeda's young remote team secured a property at about 60% of market value from a seller strained by mortgage payments.
- The seller first hoped for a price near market value, so building trust early was key to closing that gap.
- Investing books agree the discount comes from solving the seller's problem, not from squeezing the price.
- A shared CRM, task management tools and virtual meetings kept a team in different locations aligned.
Table of Contents
- Why Buying Below Market Value Starts With the Seller's Problem
- The Deal at a Glance
- Challenge One: A Seller Under Financial Strain
- Challenge Two: A Seller Who Wanted Market Value
- Challenge Three: A Team Spread Across Locations
- The Results: About 60% of Market Value, and a Satisfied Seller
- How to Price a Below Market Value Offer
- Where to Find More Below Market Value Properties
- Treat a Distressed Seller Fairly (It Protects the Deal)
- Conclusion: The Discount Follows the Solution
- Frequently Asked Questions
- References
Why Buying Below Market Value Starts With the Seller's Problem
Every investor wants to buy below market value. But fewer want to sit through what it takes. Usually that means a seller under pressure, a number that sounds low and a team that must stay in sync.
Still, Nathan Umeda's young, remote team did it anyway. They secured a property at about 60% of market value, roughly 40% below, from a seller strained by mortgage payments. And they did it without a hard sell. Here at Hesel Media, we see this pattern often: fair discounts follow clear solutions.
So how do you buy real estate below market value without crossing ethical lines? Below, we cover the team's playbook, a pricing framework from four investing books and the fairness rules that protect the deal.
What "below market value" actually means
Fannie Mae's Selling Guide defines market value as the most probable price a property should bring in a competitive and open market under fair sale conditions. In other words, it is what a typical buyer would pay after normal exposure.
Of course, sellers rarely give up that number for nothing. Instead, they accept less when the open market can't solve their problem. That might be a payment they can't carry, repairs they can't fund or a timeline a listing can't meet. Your discount is the price of the solution you provide.
The Deal at a Glance
First, here are the facts the case study reports. Nothing below is estimated.
| Deal element | What happened |
|---|---|
| Buyer | Nathan Umeda's young team, working remotely from different locations |
| Seller situation | Strained by mounting mortgage payments |
| Seller's starting hope | A price close to market value |
| Approach | Built trust early and explained the pricing clearly |
| Price | About 60% of market value, roughly 40% below |
| Coordination | Customized CRM, task management tools and virtual meetings |
| Outcome | High profit margin after repairs, on-time closing, relieved seller |
Challenge One: A Seller Under Financial Strain
The seller was under heavy financial pressure from mounting mortgage payments. So they saw selling as their way out. Still, they needed assurance that nobody was taking advantage of them.
For Nathan's team, that meant walking a fine line. After all, the offer had to make financial sense for the buyer while addressing the seller's most pressing concerns. So balancing profit with compassion became the center of their negotiation strategy.
What the books say about payment pressure
Ralph Roberts writes that, for owners who have started missing payments, the early stage is the best time to act. In 90% or more of the foreclosures he worked on, the owners' best option was to sell and cut their losses (Roberts et al., 2022). In short, selling early preserves options that disappear later.
However, Roberts is just as clear about ethics. He urges investors never to take advantage of homeowners and reminds them that any equity in the home belongs to the owners (Roberts et al., 2022). Indeed, that balance is exactly what Nathan's team aimed for: a real discount and a seller left better off.
Distressed seller rules vary by state
Many states regulate purchases from owners in or near foreclosure, including disclosures, cancellation rights and equity protections. Have a local real estate attorney review your contracts before you sign. This is not legal advice.
Challenge Two: A Seller Who Wanted Market Value
Like many sellers, this one started out hoping for a price close to market value. As a result, their early resistance to a much lower offer made the negotiation harder.
Nathan's team built trust early and clearly explained the reasoning behind their pricing. Then they showed how accepting the offer could resolve the seller's financial challenges. It wasn't a hard sell. Rather, it was a win-win both sides could accept.
Solve the problem, then talk price
Scott, Ferguson and Scott put it bluntly. In their words, success doesn't come from knowing how to negotiate. Instead, it comes from solving the problems that push the other party into the deal in the first place (Scott et al., 2019). That is the core of every fair below market value deal.
The same authors note that inexperienced negotiators fixate on price, while skilled ones use terms to find creative solutions (Scott et al., 2019). For example, terms include closing date, repairs, possession and who pays which costs. Each one can matter more to a stressed seller than a few thousand dollars.
They also suggest speaking the other party's language. So if you think in interest rates but the seller thinks in monthly payments, switch to monthly payments (Scott et al., 2019). For a seller strained by mortgage payments, that framing makes the relief concrete.
Get to "that's right" before you name a number
Chris Voss treats "that's right" as a breakthrough moment. As summarized, a string of polite yeses means you haven't truly connected yet. Instead, the real shift comes when the other side hears their situation summarized and agrees with it (Essential Insight Summaries, 2021).
In practice, that means recapping the seller's situation before you present an offer. Try: "So the payments are stretching you, and you want this done without more repairs. Is that right?" Then explain how your number solves exactly that. For more on presenting offers, see our real estate deal negotiation strategies.
The discount is a trade, not a trick
A seller accepts less when you remove a burden the open market can't. Hesel Media's trained Inside Sales Agents qualify new inquiries first, so your team starts the call already knowing the seller's real problem.
Challenge Three: A Team Spread Across Locations
The team worked from different locations. Naturally, that made the negotiation, the paperwork and the follow-ups harder to manage. Even so, clear, consistent communication kept the deal on track.
Specifically, Nathan's team relied on structured workflows and regular updates to stay aligned. A customized CRM let them track sellers, automate follow-ups and organize contracts in one central place. Meanwhile, task management platforms and virtual meetings kept every team member informed throughout the deal.
Build the team before the deal arrives
Robert Shemin warns that most real estate investors are a team of one, and he urges readers to build a real team instead (Shemin, 2005). Specifically, his list includes an agent, a title or closing agent, a real estate lawyer, an accountant and a contractor who can price repairs.
He also stresses systems. For example, he recommends a separate business bank account and a separate folder for every property (Shemin, 2005). For a remote team, that folder becomes a shared digital file everyone can reach. Our guide to virtual wholesaling real estate covers more remote workflows.
| Remote team need | Tool or habit Nathan's team used | Book-backed addition |
|---|---|---|
| One source of truth | Customized CRM | One digital folder per property (Shemin, 2005) |
| Task ownership | Task management platform | Named owner for every step |
| Alignment | Virtual meetings and regular updates | Fixed weekly deal review |
| Expert backup | Not reported | Lawyer, title agent, contractor (Shemin, 2005) |
"A remote team can close like a local one when every seller detail lives in one place."
Hesel Media
The Results: About 60% of Market Value, and a Satisfied Seller
Nathan Umeda's team secured a property at about 60% of market value and closed on time. Here is the scorecard:
- Deal secured at about 60% of market value: The discount created a high profit margin after necessary repairs.
- Smooth workflow across locations: The remote team coordinated well and closed on time.
- Seller satisfaction: The seller's financial burden eased, thanks to the team's empathetic and transparent approach.
The case study captured the team's approach this way: "Closing this deal wasn't just about the numbers, it was about listening to the seller, working as a team, and staying focused on the goal."
Of course, that was one of our best results, not a typical one. Outcomes depend on market, budget, offer and follow-up speed.
How to Price a Below Market Value Offer
Now for the math. First, start from what the house will be worth after repairs. Then subtract repairs, holding costs, closing costs and your profit. The result sets your ceiling. So if the seller needs more than that, the deal isn't below market value for you.
Here is a hypothetical example to show the arithmetic. These numbers are illustrative only and are not from Nathan's deal.
| Line item (hypothetical) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Market value after repairs | $200,000 |
| Repairs | minus $35,000 |
| Holding and closing costs | minus $15,000 |
| Target profit | minus $30,000 |
| Maximum offer | $120,000 (60% of $200,000) |
Clearly, the costs add up quickly. That's why a price near 60% of market value can still be fair. After all, the seller trades equity for speed and relief, while the buyer takes on repairs, risk and carrying costs.
Where to Find More Below Market Value Properties
You find below market value properties by finding sellers with a problem the open market can't solve fast. Then you reach them before other buyers do. So target situations, not just listings.
- Motivated seller campaigns: Inbound ads bring you sellers who already want an offer, so your first call starts with a problem to solve.
- Off-market sources: Lists and direct outreach can surface sellers before a property hits the market. Our off-market property guide compares the main sources.
- Discount-creating situations: Mortgage strain, inherited houses, heavy repairs and relocations all push owners to trade price for speed.
- Follow-up: A seller who says "not yet" today can be next quarter's deal. Our real estate lead reactivation campaign guide shows how to restart quiet conversations.
For a different kind of distressed purchase, see how Jason got a fix and flip under contract in 3 days.
Treat a Distressed Seller Fairly (It Protects the Deal)
A below market value deal holds up best when the seller understands the trade. For example, Nathan's team explained its pricing and showed how the offer solved the seller's problem. That transparency is also your best defense if anyone questions the deal later.
Also, for sellers behind on a mortgage, free help exists, and pointing them to it builds trust. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau directs homeowners to HUD-approved housing counselors, who offer independent advice, often at little or no cost. A seller who has heard their options and still picks your offer is a seller who closes.
Finally, keep your own records clean: your pricing logic, what you disclosed and what the seller agreed to.
"The best below market value deal is one the seller would choose again after hearing every option."
Hesel Media
Want More Sellers Who Need a Real Solution?
Hesel Media runs Meta campaigns for real estate investors and staffs them with trained Inside Sales Agents who qualify new inquiries and book them straight onto your calendar.
Book Your Free Strategy CallConclusion: The Discount Follows the Solution
How to buy real estate below market value comes down to one idea. Solve a seller's problem better than the open market can, and explain your number honestly. Nathan Umeda's team did both and secured a property at about 60% of market value.
The team was young and remote. Yet neither mattered, because the process held up. A shared CRM, clear roles and regular check-ins kept everyone aligned.
So build the same habits before your next deal arrives. And if you want more sellers like this one on your calendar, Hesel Media pairs Meta motivated seller campaigns with trained ISAs who qualify new inquiries for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you buy real estate below market value?
How do you buy real estate below market value? You find sellers whose problem the open market can't solve quickly, then offer a clear solution and explain your pricing honestly. The discount comes from the trade the seller chooses: speed, certainty or relief in exchange for some equity. Nathan Umeda's team followed this path. They secured a property at about 60% of market value from a seller strained by mortgage payments, without a hard sell. Negotiation authors argue that the best deals come from solving the problems that motivate the seller, not from pressure (Scott et al., 2019). Roberts adds a firm ethical line: never take advantage of owners, because their equity is theirs (Roberts et al., 2022). Finally, run your numbers first. Start from the after-repair value, subtract costs and profit, and let that set your ceiling.
What does below market value mean?
Below market value means a price lower than what a property would most likely bring in an open, competitive sale. Fannie Mae defines market value as the most probable price under fair sale conditions. So a below market value price reflects the seller trading equity for speed or certainty.
Why would a seller accept an offer below market value?
A seller accepts an offer below market value when speed, certainty or relief matters more than top price. Nathan's seller faced mounting mortgage payments and saw selling as the way out. Then the team's clear explanation of how the offer solved that problem closed the gap.
Is buying a house below market value ethical?
Buying a house below market value is ethical when the seller understands the trade and chooses it freely. So explain your pricing, avoid pressure and welcome outside advice. Also, sellers behind on payments can talk to a HUD-approved housing counselor, often at little or no cost.
How do you negotiate with a seller who wants market value?
To negotiate with a seller who wants market value, build trust first. Then summarize their situation until they agree with it, and explain how you reached your number. Nathan's team used this approach with a seller who first hoped for a price close to market value.
How do remote investing teams stay aligned on a deal?
Remote investing teams stay aligned with a shared CRM, task management tools and regular virtual meetings. Nathan Umeda's team worked from different locations and used these tools to track sellers, automate follow-ups and keep contracts in one place until closing.
Is 60% of market value a realistic offer?
Whether 60% of market value is realistic depends on repairs, holding costs and the seller's situation. Typically, once you subtract those costs and a fair profit, some distressed deals can land near that range. Nathan's team reached about 60% because the offer solved a real problem.
References
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (n.d.). Find a housing counselor. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/find-a-housing-counselor/
- Essential Insight Summaries. (2021). Summary: Never split the difference: Negotiating as if your life depended on it, by Chris Voss. Essential Insight Summaries.
- Fannie Mae. (n.d.). B4-1.1-01, Definition of market value. Selling Guide. https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.1-01/definition-market-value
- Roberts, R. R., Kraynak, J., & Roberts, K. (2022). Foreclosure investing for dummies (2nd ed.). John Wiley & Sons.
- Scott, J., Ferguson, M., & Scott, C. (2019). The book on negotiating real estate: Expert strategies for getting the best deals when buying investment properties. BiggerPockets Publishing.
- Shemin, R. (2005). 40 days to success in real estate investing. John Wiley & Sons.




.webp)
